The Difference Between Alcoholics Anonymous AA and Narcotics Anonymous NA Menifee, CA Addiction Treatment Center

Our programme is a set of principles written so simply that we can follow them in our daily lives. NA believes in an abstinence model of recovery, which means being completely drug free. But if you’re addicted to opioids, you may be taking buprenorphine maintenance therapy (BMT). The group’s official position is that the only criteria for membership is a desire to stop using drugs. Generalizability of the results is limited to alcohol-dependent individuals from Poland participating in AA.

The measure consists of three factor components, each consisting of five items. These three components may map quite well onto the research material on correlates of teen AA/NA participation and reasons for not participating. The benefits component would seem to be related to youths’ having friends that do not use, need for support related to less parental involvement, being motivated for abstinence, and being open to spirituality (connection, meditation/prayer, spiritual way of life). The severity component would seem to be related to youths’ feeling hopeless, experiencing prior treatment, being involved in relatively long treatment, having worse drug use problems, having worse problems at school, and suffering legal problems. Youth that have already suffered a fair amount may not care as much about autonomy issues or duration of use. The barriers component would seem to be related to a tendency to externalize problems, fear of experiencing rejection by older persons, limit testing on traditions/rituals, and difficulties with transportation to meetings.

We did many people great harm, but most of all we harmed ourselves. Through our inability to accept personal responsibilities we were actually creating our own problems. Located in Central Ohio, our comprehensive addiction treatment facility offers several levels of care to fit the needs of each individual.

  1. After the conversation, Dr. Bob would have one more beer then never drink again.
  2. Currently, only 10% of the estimated 1.4 million teens with an alcohol or illicit drug problem are receiving treatment compared to 20% of adults (Office of Applied Studies, 2002).
  3. Seven of eight articles were included from the review of Kelly and Myers (2007).
  4. “Gradually, my drinking started squeezing all three of those out of my life,” Marlon says.

There aren’t any higher powers involved, and addiction tends to be considered a habit rather than a disease. AA and NA literature, like the Big Books, are full of the reasoning behind the recovery from addiction 12 steps and tools to help navigate sobriety. AA uses a 12-step model that begins with a person admitting that they’re powerless over alcohol and that their lives had become unmanageable.

Latest Stories from ProPublica

Members openly talk about their struggles and successes and develop problem-solving skills, as well as friendships with others, comforted in the knowledge that they are not alone in their plight. The good news is that it’s not impossible to recover from alcohol and substance addiction. There are many programs and treatment options for alcohol and substance abuse disorders. In this article, we will be discussing the role of Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous in recovery and the difference between the two. So if you or a loved one is struggling with alcohol addiction or substance abuse disorder, this resource hopes to shed some light and give you information as to which community-based program is fit for you or your loved one. In a MATCH project AA attendance, number of steps completed, and identifying oneself as an AA member were identified as predictors of one-year post-treatment drinking outcomes [11].

You Don’t Have to Choose AA or NA

The achieved results have confirmed that involvement in AA is positively related to existential well-being, which in turn positively predicts subjective well-being including life satisfaction as well as positive and negative affect. It was confirmed that AA involvement in self-help groups indirectly via existential well-being is related to subjective well-being. Considering the discussion above regarding correlates of AA/NA teen participation, and reasons for not participating, other novel means to motivate attendance might be examined. In thinking about new directions, I considered the Survey of Readiness for Alcoholics Anonymous (SYRAAP) literature by Kingree, Simpson, Thompson, McCrady, and Tonigan (2006) and Kingree, Simpson, Thompson, McCrady, Tonigan, and Lautenschlager (2007). This assessment device was found to predict AA participation (frequency of meeting attendance, involvement with AA activities and experiences) at a 6-month follow-up assessment among 217 adults (37% that were 18–29 years old at baseline).

AA 12 Steps

We are not connected with any political, religious, or law enforcement groups, and are under no surveillance at any time. Anyone may join us, regardless of age, race, sexual identity, creed, marijuana withdrawal: symptoms timeline and tips for coping religion or lack of religion. Narcotics Anonymous and Alcoholics Anonymous follow the same format, have similar guidelines, and believe in the same tools to help those struggling with addiction.

NA 12 Steps

There are a number of wellness amenities, including nutrition services, a massage room, and gym. Clients are able to meet with our team of doctors, psychiatrists, and therapists weekly to be supervised and advised through treatment. Like AA, Celebrate Recovery takes place in group settings where people tell stories of their past and background. Attendants are given sponsors who will hold them accountable for maintaining complete abstinence from their addiction. As seen, Celebrate Recovery is a far more religious version of AA, even promoting the very first steps of AA that people are powerless over their addictions and must surrender to a higher power.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top